PUSHING BACK: Eleanor McCullen (left) stands at the painted edge of a buffer zone outside a Planned Parenthood clinic in Boston.
Associated Press/Photo by Steven Senne
PUSHING BACK: Eleanor McCullen (left) stands at the painted edge of a buffer zone outside a Planned Parenthood clinic in Boston.

Sidewalk speech

Abortion | Pro-life counselors take to the Supreme Court laws to restrict their quiet but effective work

It’s one of the coldest days of the season so far in southeastern Nebraska. A snowstorm approaches from the west, and the winter wind gives bite to the already chilled air. But the weather hasn’t kept a half dozen people, their faces wrapped in scarves, from standing on a sidewalk beside a busy four-lane road. They have stood out here before, enduring worse conditions, weather and otherwise.

Some drivers in passing cars honk and wave at those bundled up on the sidewalk. But these people, their backs turned to the street, ignore the drivers. They face a two-story building sitting beyond a sign warning in red letters: “No trespassing. Violators will be prosecuted.” The building is about 30 feet away and partially hidden by large bushes. Inside, Planned Parenthood operates a mega-clinic occupying the entire first floor. Today will be a day of abortions here.

The pro-life counselors gather as near as they can to the building. They don’t have their heads bent just to soften the blow from the December winds. They are praying for the woman heading toward the clinic’s doors. “Can we help you with something before you go in?” one of the counselors cries out. “You want some information? We have resources.”

We see you’ve been enjoying the content on our exclusive member website. Ready to get unlimited access to all of WORLD’s member content?
Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.
(Don’t worry. It only takes a sec—and you don’t have to give us payment information right now.)

Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.

“You don’t have to go in there,” another pleads. “We want to help you.”

Sidewalk counselors like these can be found most days outside many abortion clinics across the nation. But the abortion lobby is trying to push the counselors farther back, limiting the amount of information a woman can receive at her moment of crisis.

In 2007, lawmakers in Massachusetts approved a measure creating a 35-foot “buffer zone” to keep pro-life volunteers away from abortion clinics. Cities such as Chicago, San Francisco, and Portland, Maine, have passed similar measures.

Eleanor McCullen, a 77-year-old grandmother who has spent the last 13 years counseling women outside of a Boston abortion clinic, is pushing back. She is challenging the Massachusetts law for restricting her free speech on a public sidewalk. Her gentle presence has helped more than 80 frightened, tearful women choose life instead of abortion. But she says the law prevents her from reaching more with her message of love. Her case has made it to the U.S. Supreme Court where the justices are expected to make a ruling in June.

“It is at its core a censorship case,” said legal analyst Mary Reichard. The law “makes it a crime even to hand out pamphlets within 35 feet of an abortion business.”

During oral arguments before the Supreme Court on Jan. 15, Mark Rienzi, an attorney for the plaintiffs, said the First Amendment prohibits a law that “makes it illegal to even engage in consensual conversation, quiet conversation, on a public sidewalk, an act that makes that a criminal act for which Mrs. McCullen can go to prison.”

Rienzi argued the sidewalk counselors’ speech is peaceful, an argument supported by the actions of counselors back in Nebraska. The counselors don’t scream, and they follow strict rules: no insults, no talking down to the women, and no violence. Believing they serve as living testaments to the patients, they spend more time praying than talking.

When a young woman comes outside the clinic to smoke a cigarette, one sidewalk counselor drops to her knees and starts to pray. The girl’s boyfriend stands between her and the counselors as the pro-life volunteers speak from behind a white line painted on the pavement marking how close they can get.

“Please, honey,” says Candace Griswold, who has been a sidewalk counselor for eight years, “don’t go through with this. I wish you would talk to us for a minute for yourself and your baby.”

Some of the sidewalk volunteers here have had eggs thrown at them or been pepper sprayed. But they keep coming. The night before my visit more than 75 people came to a prayer vigil outside the clinic. During days abortions are performed, sidewalk counselors work in shifts and are present from 7:30 a.m. until the clinic closes. On most days an armed guard sits in a truck parked near the clinic’s entrance, making sure the counselors don’t get too close.

“We’ve got rosaries, and they’ve got guns,” Griswold says.

IN 2000, THE U.S. SUPREME COURT upheld a Colorado law creating an 8-foot buffer zone around an abortion center’s entrance. But there are four new justices on the court, including two—Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito—who may side with the three dissenters of the Colorado ruling who remain on the court. Only two justices who supported that ruling remain on the court.


You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading


    Power campaigns

    The GOP is fighting to maintain control of Congress…


    Troubling ties

    Under the Clinton State Department, influence from big money…