Michael Sears/Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel/AP

The long view

Politics | Wisconsin's budget legislation has brought a fierce energy to Democratic voters, but the bill means that liberal public sector unions could lose a lot of political power in the long run

Issue: "Clutching two, dropping four," April 23, 2011

Wisconsin State Rep. Michelle Litjens, 38, a freshman Republican, delivered the assembly's opening prayer the day the chamber passed Gov. Scott Walker's original budget bill at the end of February. Democratic legislators shouted her down, she said. After the assembly passed the bill, a Democratic legislator, Gordon Hintz, said to her, "You're [expletive] dead." He apologized for the threat after the press reported it. Litjens said she understood that he was exhausted-they had been in session 61 hours straight as Democrats offered 84 amendments to slow the bill's passage-but he had "no excuse." Police provided protection to some Republican lawmakers as they left the chamber after the vote, while Democrats threw papers in the air in frustration.

Litjens was in her office nearly two weeks later on March 9 when the Senate removed the fiscal elements of the budget bill and passed the bill that curtailed collective bargaining for certain public sector unions, without long-absent Democratic senators. The move enraged protestors. The Capitol police came over the intercom urging legislators to leave the building as quickly as possible, but Litjens needed to finish up some work, and disregarded the warning several times until she heard a swelling roar as protestors entered the Capitol.

The police officers told her they didn't have enough manpower to protect her, so a kind Democrat passed her an AFL-CIO button-a fist shaped like the state of Wisconsin-which she pinned on so she could pass through the crowd. On the ground she noticed protestors from Organizing for America, President Obama's campaign organization that opposed the budget bill and the collective bargaining measure. "He didn't teach his people much civility," Litjens said. As she told me this story, after ordering a bowl of cottage cheese with wheat toast, she pulled out the button the Democrat gave her. Now she keeps it in her purse.

We see you’ve been enjoying the content on our exclusive member website. Ready to get unlimited access to all of WORLD’s member content?
Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.
(Don’t worry. It only takes a sec—and you don’t have to give us payment information right now.)

Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.

The state Capitol is quieter but the fierce protests have enthused Democrats, who are working now to ensure Walker reaps the whirlwind. And not just Walker: The Wisconsin backlash is sending signals to the new crop of Republican governors that are attempting measures similar to Walker's.

So where is the next Wisconsin? Most states are having conversations about cutting pensions and benefits to government employees, even in New York and California. But few are undermining public sector unions' political power like Wisconsin did in the bill the legislature passed, which included a measure ending mandatory dues that partly go to fund unions' political activities. Pennsylvania's Repub­lican legislature has introduced a similar measure forbidding mandatory union dues for public employees, and Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett, a Republican, has said he would support the bill but doubts it will make it to his desk.

Other states are focusing on curtailing collective bargaining power and are reaping a milder whirlwind than Wisconsin so far. The Service Employees International Union (SEIU) is holding rallies around Ohio, which just passed legislation curtailing public unions' collective bargaining rights. Tennessee's Republican legislature is also working on legislation to limit the education union's collective bargaining. James Sherk, an expert on labor policy at the Heritage Foundation, said Tennessee Republicans "are being somewhat wishy-washy on the issue" but are moving forward because "the Tea Party is holding their feet to the fire."

The reluctance to confront the public sector unions as brashly as Walker did is more understandable in light of the unions' aggressive response in Wisconsin. Thirteen state legislators have been recalled in the history of the United States, but 16 are facing potential recalls right now in the Wisconsin Senate alone. Opponents of Republican Sen. Dan Kapanke recently gathered enough signatures to trigger a recall vote in coming weeks, subject to court challenges. Republicans, too, have gathered enough signatures to trigger a recall for Democratic Sen. Robert Wirch, who was among those who fled the state to prevent a vote on Walker's bill. The Republicans will lose their Senate majority if they shed a net of three seats. Walker could also be subject to a recall once he has been in office a year, but only one governor has been successfully recalled in U.S. history. This is all after Republicans gained sweeping victories at every political level in Wisconsin in November.

The enthused Democratic base also turned out in large numbers for the previously ignored Wisconsin Supreme Court race on April 5. Conservative Supreme Court Justice David Prosser's reelection bid against Wisconsin Assistant Attorney General JoAnne Kloppenburg became a proxy battle over the public union legislation. Kloppenburg implied in her campaign that Prosser is a rubber stamp for Walker. Outside groups poured money into the race, on both sides: Prosser and Kloppenberg could spend $300,000 each in their publicly funded campaigns, but outside groups spent at least $3.1 million on television ads for the race.


You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading


    Troubling ties

    Under the Clinton State Department, influence from big money…