Sam Craston/Genesis for WORLD

Paycheck program

Welfare | By encouraging work, the Earned Income Tax Credit is one form of social spending that many conservatives can support

Issue: "Tick, tick, tick ...," May 7, 2011

CONCORD, N.C.-As Washington's budget battles continue, welfare expenditures are often the prime example of spending that hurts the people it's supposed to help-but one $59 billion program, the Earned Income Tax Credit, is mainly an exception.

Lorie Conley benefits from that program. Her uniform T-shirt is stained with marinara sauce and minestrone soup after a lunch shift in the kitchen of the Olive Garden in Concord, N.C., just north of Charlotte. Her emotions are frayed after hours of pulling hot plates of lasagna and gathering cheese graters scattered across the counters. She's tired and she's dirty, but as she absentmindedly twirls her fork in a plate of pasta, her mind is still working, doing the math.

Conley, a single mother, raises three children and makes $12.35 an hour as a culinary assistant. "A lot of times, it takes every single thing I get on my check to pay bills," she said. Her problem now, after working at Olive Garden for five years, is that her preteen son has juvenile diabetes. "I can't have just any babysitter watch him," she said. "I need someone who knows what to do if he gets sick or goes unconscious." She changed her work availability to fit her son's needs, unable to leave him at night. Since switching to lunch shifts, her 40 hours are down to 25.

We see you’ve been enjoying the content on our exclusive member website. Ready to get unlimited access to all of WORLD’s member content?
Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.
(Don’t worry. It only takes a sec—and you don’t have to give us payment information right now.)

Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.

Conley works hard to provide for her kids. She rides the bus to cut down gas costs. She discontinued cable television in her apartment. And she is thankful for the one governmental program for the poor that most conservatives like, the Earned Income Tax Credit. The EITC last year provided Conley with a $5,000 check.

She used the money to buy school clothes for her children, to pay her rent in advance, and to save for education: She plans to attend Rowan-Cabarrus Community College and earn a degree in accounting.

First enacted in 1975, the EITC is a federal tax credit for low-income workers. Hailed as an alternative to traditional, handout-based welfare programs, supporters of the EITC say it encourages work and stimulates the economy. While federal welfare programs can keep families from working for fear of losing benefits, the EITC recipients must work to be eligible, and as families increase their income the credit decreases at a slower rate than the income increases.

Della Knowles, a social worker in Cabarrus County, which includes Concord, contrasts the money distributed through the EITC with money handed out to people not working. "Most people who are on welfare believe they are entitled to that welfare," she said. "I think it's a broken system. It's draining our economy." Knowles understands the need for temporary assistance. When her husband was laid off, she enrolled her children in Medicaid for a year. Speaking of the welfare programs, she said, "That's what all these programs were supposed to be-they were supposed to be temporary." She sees the EITC as a greater benefit to society. "The EITC is a reward for people who aren't on all these programs."

Conley is not unusual. I interviewed Laura Stevens, who works as a server at Olive Garden and trainer averaging 25-30 hours of work each week. She studies at a local community college with a full class load and is a single mom to two young girls. The financial strain of supporting her family on a tip-based income has caused Stevens to consider welfare as an alternative, but not seriously enough to pay a visit to the Division of Social Services. She doesn't want her girls growing up in government housing, concerned for their safety. "If I don't need it, I don't want it," she said. Instead, when she isn't working, she focuses on school with plans to establish a nursing career.

Like Conley, Stevens uses the tax credit to pay her bills in advance. "It puts me ahead massively." She also deposits $1,800 in savings each year for her daughters' college education, and uses what's left over to buy them birthday presents. Reflecting on what life would be like without the EITC, her hands instinctively cupped her face. "It would be horrible," she said. "My kids wouldn't have a birthday."

Qualifications for a family to receive the EITC are based primarily on income and dependent children. The maximum credit is $5,666, with money sent as part of an individual's tax refund check. Conley's annual income of less than $16,000 brought her that $5,000 check. Amy Hiester, a server with one dependent child, who makes between $150 and $400 a week in tips, received a $3,000 credit.


You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading


    Power campaigns

    The GOP is fighting to maintain control of Congress…


    Troubling ties

    Under the Clinton State Department, influence from big money…