Reviews > Books

War reads

Books | Election season is coming and Iraq rhetoric will be humming. Get your facts and perspective in order now

Issue: "Left behind," June 28, 2008

A year ago respected Johns Hopkins scholar Fouad Ajami mused, "You go to war with the press you have." Reporters in Iraq have been more attuned to the politics of the beltway than of Baghdad, too confined to the Green Zone's spin zone, and largely uninformed about the densely woven history of Iraq from the time of Abraham, a history that includes not only Sunni and Shiite elite but Jews, Nestorian Christians, Persians, and a league of other people groups. The result, according to Ajami: "a literary yield [that] has so far been a literary desert."

With facts on the ground improving plus political change in the Washington wind, the documented record of a five-and-a-half-year war told by its scribes is more vital than ever. Out of the morass of journalistic memoirs, the apologetics from scholarly experts of left and right, the soldiers' stories, and the armchair bloggers, a few gems emerge. Judging from the mail and questions received by WORLD, never before has a U.S. war been so eagerly discussed and its actualities so stubbornly misunderstood. These volumes each offer unique perspectives along with a measure of relief from propaganda and cliché.

Moment of Truth in Iraq: How a New "Greatest Generation" of American Soldiers is Turning Defeat and Disaster into Victory and Hope - by Michael Yon (Richard Vigilante Books, 2008)

We see you’ve been enjoying the content on our exclusive member website. Ready to get unlimited access to all of WORLD’s member content?
Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.
(Don’t worry. It only takes a sec—and you don’t have to give us payment information right now.)

Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.

Former Green Beret Michael Yon decided to take blogging about the war a step further than the average web jockey. In 2005 just as the war turned decidedly nasty he showed up in Mosul and Anbar Province to see insurgency up close-a self-taught, self-supporting, over-40 freelance journalist. That sort of hubris has gotten other soloists killed. Yon parlayed it, along with military savvy and a cold-eyed but warm-hearted approach to both U.S. military personnel and Iraqis, into well-written, carefully detailed dispatches. They were read mostly by his blog fans (whom he frequently asked for money to keep it all going) until media outlets like National Review and The Weekly Standard, along with a slew of notable bloggers, drew attention to his battlefield reporting. If this war has an Ernie Pyle, Yon is it.

Now the dispatches have become a book, edited into a nearly seamless commentary on war at its closest range. Yon's faith and patriotism are refreshing but not blind: "We made huge mistakes early on," he writes from Baquba, "and now we pump blood and gold into the desert to pay for those blunders."

The Assassins' Gate: America in Iraq- by George Packer (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2005)

In the genre of insider tell-alls-a crowded field of books like Thomas Ricks' Fiasco, Rajiv Chandrasekaran's Imperial Life in the Emerald City, and the latest by one of the insiders himself, Pentagon war planner Doug Feith's War and Decision-George Packer's now aging chronicle remains unbeatable. One reason is that Packer, an award-winning staff writer for The New Yorker, is unbeatable at his craft. Another is that he spent shoe-leather as thoroughly as any money-exchanger hawking stacks of inflationary Iraqi dinars on Baghdad's streets.

The guy combed not only the Green Zone's windowless hallways but Sadr City's comfortless streets. He made it his business to be in Iraq's schools and liquor shops and hospitals and mosques and to be with its shopkeepers and intellectuals and its politicians large and small. As a result he chronicles not only the chaos that substituted for a coherent Bush policy post-invasion, he sees one of the key philosophical mistakes missed by pundits right and left: "What had been left out of the planning were the Iraqis themselves." Packer's account is at once enormously disheartening and endearingly human. If this war has a David Halberstam, Packer is it.

Instructions for American Servicemen in Iraq During World War II - by the United States Army (reprinted by University of Chicago Press from original, 1943)

"You have been ordered to Iraq (i - RAHK) as part of the world-wide offensive to beat Hitler. You will enter Iraq both as a soldier and as an individual. That is our strength-if we are smart enough to use it. It can be our weakness if we aren't."

Thus begins "A Short Guide To Iraq" issued to every U.S. soldier entering the theater in 1943 to assist British units guarding against Nazi infiltration. If only U.S. military personnel from 2003 on had something similar. Indeed, U.S. army commander and counterterrorism expert John Nagl writes in an introduction to this reprint, "I wish that I had read it before beginning my own yearlong tour in Al Anbar in late 2003!"

Comments

You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading

     

    Together again

    Movie’s Black Album hits the right post-Beatles note but…

    Advertisement