Oded Balilty/AP

Men in black

Israel | Messianic believers and ultra-Orthodox clash in Israeli town

Issue: "Shattered dreams," April 5, 2008

The latest scuffle on the streets of this small Israeli town in the Negev desert came as no real surprise to Eddie Beckford. Arad's ultra-Orthodox crowd has taunted, threatened, and assaulted the modest Messianic Jewish presence for years, holding massive demonstrations outside their homes and even torching the local chess club and Bible shop-a popular destination for the town's Russian immigrants.

What confounded Beckford this time around were the events following the skirmish. As one of the town's Orthodox tried to snatch his video camera on Feb. 27, Beckford and Steve Kaplan, an American tourist, shielded themselves. Both were assaulted, they claim, as they pushed the man away, but local police arrested only the victims and recorded testimony from the ultra-Orthodox community alone. Kaplan was released, but a judge placed Beckford on house arrest in Beersheva, miles away from Arad.

Although Israel has always had a strong ultra-Orthodox Jewish presence, defense lawyers in Israel say their clout in the region is growing, and that they have illegal ties with government agencies that have resulted in undue hardships for non-Jews, including a new campaign to revoke the citizenship of Messianic Jews.

We see you’ve been enjoying the content on our exclusive member website. Ready to get unlimited access to all of WORLD’s member content?
Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.
(Don’t worry. It only takes a sec—and you don’t have to give us payment information right now.)

Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.

As many Christians enthusiastically prepare for excursions to Israel in the coming months to commemorate the country's 60th anniversary, local believers caution against ignoring the reality on the ground. "Many Christians are shocked to hear what these men in black are doing to the Christians here. Many have the mistaken idea that these men are somehow 'holy,' but that is very far from the truth," Beckford's wife, Lura, said.

One of the primary instigators in the quest to stifle the Christian presence in Israel is an ultra-Orthodox organization called Yad L'Achim. In February the group placed an advertisement in one of Israel's most widely read newspapers that called for information about the location of Christian "missionaries"-a term used to describe all Christians in Israel.

Michael Decker, a senior legal analyst at the Jerusalem Center for Justice, told WORLD that there is an "illegal alliance between governmental organizations in Israel and the extreme Jewish Orthodox movement." He says Yad L'Achim is operating in conjunction with the offices of the Ministry of Interior to blacklist Messianic believers.

Christians receive a letter from the ministry calling them into their offices. Upon arrival they are questioned about their faith and religious activities and coerced into signing documents that often result in a loss of basic rights including the registration of their children in the official registry, the issuing of new identification cards, the renewal of their passport, and even citizenship.

Yad L'Achim's website divulges few specifics about its Counter Missionary Department: "We fight missionaries in a variety of ways, some of which, due to their sensitive nature, can't be described in detail." The website warns its readers that it is "vitally important to remember that any assistance provided by missionary organizations, as innocent as it might appear, ultimately leads to one thing: Jews joining up with Christians. In our battle against the missionaries we are even more motivated."

The intimidation tactics of these extremist groups are often successful at the local level, and the Beckfords tell of countless Christians who were denied essential papers, lost their jobs, and ran out of money. "Even the police are afraid to go against the Orthodox Jews because they want to keep their jobs. The policeman who arrested me told me he is afraid of losing his pension. He is due to retire next year," Lura Beckford said.

But while the ultra-Orthodox wield their influence throughout the lower levels of government, they have little influence over the nation's Supreme Court, Decker said. When Yad L'Achim challenged one of Israel's oldest churches on the legality of its building permit, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of the church, Grace and Truth Christian Congregation. The legal victory for the congregation set precedence for other congregations across Israel facing building obstacles.

But the resources to defend believers against discrimination are not always readily available. Decker says his organization is struggling for manpower, and if he passes his April bar exam, he will be one of only three Messianic believers practicing law in Israel.

Money is another obstacle. Many of Israel's Messianic Jews (and Arab Christians) live in small, isolated communities and are jobless as a result of ultra-Orthodox campaigns against Christians in their communities.

Few have the resources to fight the forces behind the discrimination and struggle to understand why Christians in the West offer unequivocal support for Jews in Israel. "One of the most discouraging things to us is when we hear that Christians are donating money to organizations run by the Orthodox. They are using that money to persecute believers. One of our harassers was waving a $40,000 check he received from a Christian organization," Lura Beckford said.


You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading


    Job-seeker friendly

    Southern California churches reach the unemployed through job fairs 


    After a fiery trial

    Intelligent design proponent David Coppedge reflects on his wrongful termination…