Columnists > Mailbag


Letters from our readers

Issue: "'Into captivity they shall go'," Feb. 24, 2007


I am incredulous that anyone would fall for the baloney coming out of the camps of Democratic presidential hopefuls regarding their newfound religion ("Faith-based campaigning," Jan. 27). When Clinton and the rest stop proclaiming a woman's right to kill her baby and opposing pro-life legislation, perhaps then their actions will match their rhetoric. Part-time Christianity doesn't cut it and they need to end the charade.
-Ron Youngclaus; St. Louis, Mo.

The left has recognized that certain aspects of its political vision find some credence in Christian ethics. This is not altogether bad, so long as one realizes that no non-Christian political vision is a substitute for Christian ethics. Too many Christians have exchanged the politics of Jesus for the politics of Rush Limbaugh. I tend to vote Republican, but I appreciate what these folks are doing.
-Robert Dailey; Durham, N.C.

We see you’ve been enjoying the content on our exclusive member website. Ready to get unlimited access to all of WORLD’s member content?
Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.
(Don’t worry. It only takes a sec—and you don’t have to give us payment information right now.)

Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.

C.S. Lewis has Screwtape explain that "the thing to do is to get a man at first to value social justice as a thing which [God] demands, and then work him on to the stage at which he values Christianity because it may produce social justice. For [God] will not be used as a convenience." Screwtape nails it. When Christ lives in you, you need to show that in all aspects of your life, including politics. Hiring religious outreach advisors smacks of using God as a convenience.
-Jean Boulanger; Mountain View, Calif.

As a member of consultant Shaun Casey's denomination, the Church of Christ, I am a bit embarrassed by his shallow notion that we owe the government simply because the money isn't ours. I agree that we are stewards of the money God has given us, but handing it over to an inefficient, wasteful bureaucracy would not in my mind constitute good stewardship. Government-funded efforts do not guarantee solutions, despite the scale of suffering Casey wants to address.
-Bob Weber; Chatham, N.J.

Many churches in our country long ago abandoned the gospel, so it's not surprising to see politicians with extensive pro-abortion rap sheets welcomed into these same pulpits to preach their humanistic mix of religiosity and "freedom of choice."
-Bob Brown; Belcamp, Md.

I see faith-based campaigning as window dressing. I hope WORLD can keep us informed of good Christian politicians who truly do believe, instead of just mouthing it.
-M. Anderson; Lander, Wyo.

Making the grade?

Joel Belz's column "Homeward bound" (Jan. 27), which describes and mocks comments I made on a recent PBS show about homeschooling, is an embarrassing piece of ad hominem attack. It always surprises me how homeschool advocates are so quick to demonize homeschool critics. Are these the character virtues they teach their children in the home? Belz writes that people like me are interested in "total control" and approvingly quotes Bruce Shortt, who claims that I have an "ideological and cultural agenda." People should read what I've written on the topic and judge for themselves.
-Rob Reich; Stanford, Calif.

From where does the government derive any right to regulate the choices that parents make as to how they choose to educate their children? Government "accountability and oversight" of education leads to the compulsory exposure of children to whatever ideas are government-approved. The right of parents alone to direct the education of their children, to the best of their understanding, should be protected.
-Peter Van Wieren; Ypsilanti, Mich.

I agree with Reich in that I want good regulations to apply to those parents who homeschool. Government has a duty to protect society at large, including children, from those who are unqualified or unwilling to teach to an acceptable level. Parents who object to government involvement in the education of their children should either make an exception for skills testing, or pursue some other way to make it very obvious that they are "making the grade."
-Trent VanderZee; Crown Point, Ind.

Bravo to Belz and Bruce Shortt. As a homeschooling father of four, I am always thrilled when someone points out that the emperor is wearing no clothes when it comes to the standard, tired arguments against homeschooling. Public education is about indoctrination, not diversity, and it encourages a boring homogeneity. Homeschooling is about learning to understand the world around us, why we're here and where we're going. No wonder Reich and his fellow travelers are running scared.
-John Carpenter; Dayton, Tenn.

Women and men

Andrée Seu has it right, again, when she points out that the Industrial Age separated us from wider community support systems, leading us to depend upon our spouses for all our emotional support ("Sharing the freight," Jan. 27). But it is more than that; creeping into society was a larger and larger sense that the women were in charge of morality, that women had to watch over men to keep them out of trouble. Men need time with men-time to plan, and do, and reminisce. We women need to back off our reluctance to such gatherings.
-Ursula Smith; Chesterfield, Mo.


You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading


    Troubling ties

    Under the Clinton State Department, influence from big money…