Should the saints go marching out?

Political Analysis | The agendas behind the publication of an October surprise book

Issue: "Too close to call," Oct. 28, 2006

From Foley to Kuo: Washington buzz last week focused on a book by former Bush staffer David Kuo that hit the shelves on Oct. 16. His Tempting Faith: An Inside Story of Political Seduction reveals-according to the breathless Free Press publicity headline-"how Bush White House Manipulated the Christian Right."

In reality, the book and its relentless publicizing-60 Minutes, Good Morning America, and other network shows, hundreds of newspaper and magazine articles-show rampant manipulation on all sides: As Kuo put it in a WORLD interview-"everyone is using everyone and everyone has his own agenda." Because I've known Kuo for over a decade and was involved in hiring him 10 years ago to direct an organization designed to promote compassionate conservatism, he and I were able to examine some issues in our interview that have received short shrift elsewhere.

But first, some background on a smart, sophisticated, and sociable 38-year-old. With those attributes and a great backstory-his Chinese dad fought Mao Tse-Tung and escaped the Communist takeover on the last boat to leave Shanghai-Kuo was able to build a resumé with all-star bosses. His first job in Washington was with the National Right to Life Committee, but then he worked (usually briefly) for Bill Bennett, Jack Kemp, John Ashcroft, Bob Dole, Ralph Reed, and George W. Bush.

We see you’ve been enjoying the content on our exclusive member website. Ready to get unlimited access to all of WORLD’s member content?
Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.
(Don’t worry. It only takes a sec—and you don’t have to give us payment information right now.)

Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.

Kuo's work as a speechwriter and aide to many famous politicians made him a bright Forrest Gump or maybe a Leonard Zelig, the character in Woody Allen's 1983 mockumentary Zelig who looks and acts like whoever is around him. (Clever editing placed Zelig in real newsreel footage of Woodrow Wilson, Babe Ruth, and others.) Kuo, like many 20- and then 30-somethings who write in the voice of others, had a hard time finding his own: Tempting Faith is his attempt to be his own man, a Christian.

Kuo's passionate need to confess-in our interview he described himself as "a poor, poor, poor pilgrim. I stink at following Jesus"-was also prompted by an operation three years ago that removed from his brain an egg-sized, malignant tumor. Doctors say the cancer may return. Five years ago I witnessed Kuo behaving like a Zelig, but cancer has a way of focusing attention.

Kuo's stated agenda, then, is to put Christ before politics, and perhaps to leave a legacy for his three daughters. Tempting Faith is far more than its highly publicized excerpts about some Bush staffers dissing Christian leaders. (That comes as no surprise, since the administration-like the GOP generally-is made up both of Christians and anti-Christian libertarians.)

The publicity barrage has ignored some valuable specific detail on how the Bush faith-based initiative went astray early on. Kuo notes that the 2001 Bush tax cut left out "the president's promised $6 billion per year in tax credits for groups helping the poor. Those tax credits had been the centerpiece of compassionate-conservative efforts for years."

The White House, Kuo charges, decided that it was more important to cut the estate tax than to help the poor and decentralize poverty-fighting. Not wanting to make the big tax bill any bigger, the Bush administration fought against key congressional staffers and succeeded in having the anti-poverty tax credits dropped.

In our interview, Kuo said that Republicans on the Senate Finance Committee were "dumbfounded" by the White House switch: It was a "direct trade" to emphasize the estate tax over the compassionate conservative agenda. Kuo stated that "everyone in the West Wing knew" about the trade "and didn't exactly protest."

Kuo includes more detail about Bush administration problems but stated that "the very last thing I wanted was some anti-Bush book for the sake of being anti-Bush." And yet, Kuo in February 2005 wrote a Beliefnet article critical of the Bush administration that received considerable attention and led to his Free Press contract. He acknowledges that he knew the anti-Bush excerpts would be liberal fodder this time as well. So why did he write this book the way he did and agree to its publication shortly before a crucial election?

Kuo in our interview gave two reasons. First, he still wants the compassionate conservative movement to succeed, and this is a way of attracting attention to its yet-unrealized potential: "If this hadn't come out now, how many conservatives would even have given it a single thought?"

Second, "The point for me is the spiritual point-Jesus must always be first, always." He wants to communicate to Christians, "Please understand that you are being used. Look shrewdly at that and remember, remember, remember that Jesus must come first."


You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading


    Power campaigns

    The GOP is fighting to maintain control of Congress…


    Troubling ties

    Under the Clinton State Department, influence from big money…