Reviews > Notable CDs

Best-selling CDs

Notable CDs | The top five most-played radio CDs according to CMJ, Issue 875

Issue: "2004 Olympics Preview," Aug. 14, 2004

Best-selling CDs

The top five most-played radio CDs according to CMJ, Issue 875

1. A GHOST IS BORN -- Wilco

Weeks on chart: 6

Style: World-weary rock, alternative folk division.

Objectionable material: "Company in My Back" (obscenities).

Worldview: "Theologians, they don't know nothing / about my soul. / . . . They thin my heart with little things / and my life with change / in so many ways. / I find more missing every day."

Overall quality: An inchoate hybrid of the luminous lethargy of Big Star's Third and the harrowing grimness of Neil Young's Tonight's the Night.

2. UH HUH HER -- PJ Harvey

Weeks on chart: 7

Style: Raw, jagged-edged angst rock (Patti Smith meets Sonic Youth).

Objectionable material: "Who the [expletive deleted]?" ; "Pocket Knife" (profanities).

Worldview: Hell hath no fury, pain, or confusion like a woman scorned, hurt, or misunderstood.

Overall quality: From her abrasive eloquence to her whisper-to-a-scream tonal shifts, Polly Jean Harvey makes the dark place from which she creates her music seem disturbingly real.

3. TO THE 5 BOROUGHS -- Beastie Boys

Weeks on chart: 5

Style: A return to the brash, late-'80s rap style that the Beastie Boys themselves pioneered, brought up to date with cruder language and Michael Moore politics.

Objectionable material: Most of the 15 tracks (profanity, obscenity, vulgarity, blasphemy).

Worldview: "Got to spread love before the world goes pop. Never again should we use the A-bomb. . . . All W.O.M.D.'s gone. We need a multilateral disarm."

Overall quality: 50 percent man, 50 percent boy, 100 percent beastie.

4. THE CURE -- The Cure

Weeks on chart: 4

Style: Maelstrom-like alternative rock.

Objectionable material: "Before Three," "Us or Them" (obscenity).

Worldview: "Death is with us all. / We suck him down with our first breath / and spit him out as we fall. / There is no terror in my heart, / no dread of the unknown, / desire for paradise to be."

Overall quality: A spoonful of hooks would help Robert Smith's prolixity and pained yelping go down.

5. TOGETHER WE'RE HEAVY -- Polyphonic Spree

Weeks on chart: 5

Style: Godspell meets Up with People.

Objectionable material: Several muted profanities on the bonus DVD.

Worldview: "If you come to a . . . Polyphonic Spree show . . . , I think you're going to experience . . . a kind of a celebration. . . . I don't know what the hell we're celebrating, but that's what it feels like to me" (bandleader Tim DeLaughter in the DVD interview).

Overall quality: Unselfconscious silliness for our politically overheated times.

In the spotlight

By the mid-'90s, as the evaporation of their original context caused them to flail about ever more unconvincingly for a new one, it became easy to ignore the Beastie Boys. With To the 5 Boroughs (Capitol), though, they demonstrate the ongoing vitality of their roots by returning to them as if 9/11 were the only significant event to have transpired since 1989's Paul's Boutique. Trading witty lines and rhymes, referencing and sampling amusingly disparate pop-cultural artifacts, they're saying it loud: They're back and proud.

There are, alas, signs that time does in fact march on-namely, their rote liberalism (which is annoying enough coming from Linda Ronstadt let alone from guys who started off as equal-opportunity offenders) and their profanity (which, given their undeniable verbal skills, feels contrived to earn that most dubious of authenticity badges, the parental-warning sticker). Proof that time sometimes stands still: not changing their name to "Beastie Men" or anything else falsely indicative of maturity.


You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading


    Good credit

    Competency-based programs offer college credentials without the debilitating cost


    Soaring sounds

    Three recent albums highlight the aesthetic and emotional range…


    Numbers matter

    Understaffing the U.S. effort in Iraq from the beginning…