Dispatches > The Buzz

Mailbag

Issue: "John Kerry: On a roll," Feb. 14, 2004

Truth in labeling

"Lawmakers, lawbreakers" (Jan. 17) was excellent. The bishops should excommunicate politicians and others who support abortion and refuse to repent. One cannot claim to be Catholic while supporting abortion any more than Jefferson could claim to be Christian while denying Christ's divinity. Why America's bishops have to convene a committee to agonize over this straightforward issue baffles me. These politicians should either strive to follow their professed faith (rather than proudly flouting it) or stop calling themselves Catholic to garner votes.

-Paul L. Veazey

We see you’ve been enjoying the content on our exclusive member website. Ready to get unlimited access to all of WORLD’s member content?
Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.
(Don’t worry. It only takes a sec—and you don’t have to give us payment information right now.)

Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.

Lake Charles, La.

Thanks to Gene Edward Veith for drawing our attention to the topic of church discipline. I pray that his article stirs both pastors and church members to practice biblical principles. It is essential that we recover church discipline, not only in the fight for the unborn but in the fight for the holiness of the church.

-Eric Schumacher

Keokuk, Iowa

I understand Mr. Veith's point in his first two paragraphs, but the argument that "My religious beliefs are against X, but I don't have the right to impose my religious beliefs on anyone else" can be legitimate, depending on the context. If X is abortion, that's one thing. If X is drinking alcohol or eating meat, that's another. This raises the question: What are the contexts in which Christians should advocate the use of government to restrict the freedom of others, and why?

-D. Eric Schansberg

New Albany, Ind.

In his generally excellent analysis, Gene Edward Veith writes that while campaigning for the presidency in 1960, John F. Kennedy "vowed not to let the head of his church usurp the sovereignty of the United States of America." But in that memorable speech Kennedy went much further. He pledged that he would not allow his religious beliefs to influence his public stands. You don't have to be Catholic to notice that Kennedy's speech created a precedent, easing the way for later politicians whose voting records were at odds with their professed religious principles.

-Philip F. Lawler

Lancaster, Mass.

Show and tell

I'm 16 years old, and abortion was a foreign word to me until I saw a photograph of the procedure in a magazine. I was horrified. I went to my mother, and she told me of all the different ways they can destroy an unborn child. That's what we need to show other teens. Show them what happens when you "just have an abortion." The NARAL websites and other groups are affecting teens' decisions on abortion ("Growing their own," Jan. 17). We need to do the same.

-Laura Wagner

Pickerington, Ohio

It was an incredible encouragement to me to see that many more teens than we realize are opposed to abortion. It is easy to think that we are alone in our beliefs, and to remain quiet. As a 17-year-old, I am right in the midst of this debate. The media and pro-choice agenda is to convince us that anyone who is not a pro-choice advocate is a biased, unintelligent individual who refuses to listen to reason and science. In reality, it is they who reject the truth.

-Emily Graham

Clay Center, Kan.

There is another reason why support for abortion among college students is falling. Perhaps 31 years of pro-choice parents availing themselves of abortion has drastically reduced the number of children they send to college relative to the number pro-life families send to college. NARAL and Planned Parenthood have to "grow their own" to offset their inevitable demographic doom.

-David DiMartino

Prospect, Ky.

Two standards

Less than a year ago I would have strongly agreed with Mr. Veith's assertion that "the state acts as God's agent when it kills those who have killed" ("Pro-life penalty," Jan. 17). In theory and based on God's word I still do. Regrettably, in our country there are two standards of justice-one for the rich and famous and another for the rest of us. Until I see the same "justice for all," I'm stuck agreeing with former Governor George Ryan of Illinois.

-David D. Needham

Rapid City, S.D.

Although the Catholic Church in modern times opposes the death penalty in most cases (there are exceptions), she would never equate the egregiousness of murdering the unborn with the state's execution of imperfect human justice against society's worst criminals. To claim that the Roman Catholic Church believes "there [is] no essential difference" misrepresents Catholic teaching.

-Tom Aranda

Bossier City, La.

That explains it

While I liked a few parts of Cold Mountain, such as the music and the character of the rough mountain girl Ruby, I was shocked by the sex scenes and lack of coherent purpose other than survival ("Cold mountain movie," Jan. 17). Thanks to Andrew Coffin for articulating why I found it so troubling.

Comments

You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading

     

    112 Weddings

    112 Weddings is an HBO documentary that may scare…