Cover Story

Heresy trials

Is a vocal Christian inherently unqualified to teach biology? Some public-school officials in Minnesota think so

Issue: "Heresy trials," Aug. 18, 2001

A current free-speech case resembles the Scopes Monkey Trial in reverse. The setting is similar-a rural community known for its shimmering lakes and rolling farms, a beleaguered but earnest teacher determined to challenge the status quo, and a pair of high-powered lawyers duking it out in court. Only instead of being lampooned for criticizing creationism, as was Tennessee teacher John Scopes in 1925, this time the teacher is being punished for critiquing evolution.

The culprit is Rod LeVake, a soft-spoken, 6'2" football coach who thought he had reached the pinnacle of his career after becoming a biology teacher in Faribault, Minn.-a mid-size farming community 45 miles south of the Twin Cities. Mr. LeVake accepted the position in 1997 after teaching junior high physical science for 13 years. "On the first day of class, I told my students that my life-long dream of teaching biology had come true. Of course, they all stared at me like I was strange," he said. Four months later, his students stared again as he gave them a farewell speech.

Religious discrimination destroyed his dream, said Mr. LeVake, an outspoken Christian who often gives invocations at school football banquets. In a federal lawsuit filed in June 1999, he said school administrators pulled him from the class mid-semester after questioning him about his Christian faith-even though he repeatedly told them he would not teach creationism. The Minnesota State Supreme Court refused his appeal, and his next stop may be the U.S. Supreme Court. "This is about whether a Christian can teach biology and whether Darwinism can be criticized," said Mr. LeVake.

We see you’ve been enjoying the content on our exclusive member website. Ready to get unlimited access to all of WORLD’s member content?
Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.
(Don’t worry. It only takes a sec—and you don’t have to give us payment information right now.)

Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.

Also at stake is whether Christian teachers in the public schools have religious freedom protection. For years, left-wing church-state groups have warned teachers against pushing religion on their students, but what if the school system uses religion to punish the teacher?

Mr. LeVake's trouble began after he informed a few colleagues of his plans to alert students about textbook errors regarding evolution. For instance, the students' textbook cited Haeckel's Embryos-scientific drawings showing similarities between different species' embryos-as a proof of evolution. Real-life photographs have since cast doubt on those similarities.

Mr. LeVake was summoned to a surprise meeting with his school principal and two other administrators, who interrogated him for two hours. "They asked me questions like, 'What are your beliefs? ... Do your students know you are a Christian? Have you ever mentioned God or the Bible in class?'" recalled Mr. LeVake. After admitting he believed in creation, he was subjected to another inquisition before the entire science department: "They went around the room and fired questions at me," he said. "I remember one person saying, 'What you believe is just like believing the earth is flat.'" At the end of the meeting, the principal, Dave Johnson, instructed Mr. LeVake to submit a position paper explaining how he planned to teach evolution.

"I don't believe an unquestioning faith in the theory of evolution is foundational to the goals I have stated in teaching my students about themselves, their responsibilities, and gaining a sense of awe for what they see around them," said Mr. LeVake in his two-page position paper. "I will teach, should the department decide that it is appropriate, the theory of evolution. I will also accompany that treatment of evolution with an honest look at the difficulties and inconsistencies of the theory without turning my class into a religious one. Anything less than this constitutes poor science."

His statement failed to appease school officials, who promptly transferred him to a chemistry class-despite the fact that he is the school's only teacher with a biology master's degree. In a letter dated May 14, 1998, superintendent Keith Dixon told Mr. LeVake that his position paper "made it clear that you cannot teach the curriculum."

"I felt like the rug had been pulled out from under me," said Mr. LeVake. "I don't mind teaching kids the theories of evolution, but I cannot just stand there and say this is truth and there aren't any problems with it. They wanted me to teach it like dogma."

By judging that Mr. LeVake was unable to teach because of his personal religious beliefs, Faribault school officials became thought police, said Francis Manion, a lawyer from the American Center for Law and Justice (ACLJ), which is representing Mr. LeVake. Citing the school syllabus's promise to teach evolution in an "impartial" and "open manner," Mr. Manion argued that Mr. LeVake "was doing exactly what the school asked him to do, but because they read into what he wants to do something they deemed to be religious, they took him off the job. In effect, it was religious prejudice."


You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading


    Troubling ties

    Under the Clinton State Department, influence from big money…