Small-town predators

National | The rape and murder of a 13-year-old boy roils Arkansas, but not the national press

Issue: "Forbes," Nov. 20, 1999

Warning:Contains graphic elements. in Rogers, Ark. - Reaching its long black arm into quiet farmlands and fall-colored mountains, Highway 62 long provided the only link between Lincoln, Prairie Grove, and Rogers-three rural communities that dot the 150-mile route east of the Oklahoma border in northern Arkansas. That was before September, though, when two homosexual men in Rogers allegedly raped and killed 13-year-old Jesse Dirkhising, a Prairie Grove resident and Lincoln middle-school student. Now the three towns are forever connected in a depressing tale of small-town sin and media double standards. The story began when Jesse accepted a weekend job from 38-year-old Davis Carpenter, an openly gay hair stylist at Regis Hair Salon who had just settled in Rogers after moving 26 times throughout the country. Jesse, who lived in a small trailer with two siblings, his mother, and her third husband, leapt at the chance to earn a few extra dollars and escape for 30-mile weekend trips to Rogers. While in Rogers, he lodged in an apartment shared by Mr. Carpenter and his 22-year-old homosexual lover, Joshua Brown. Jesse's mother, Tina Yates, said she had known Mr. Carpenter for seven years and had no qualms about letting Jesse stay with the homosexual couple. "I have a lot of gay friends," she said. "I never ever thought he [Carpenter] would hurt one of our own children." Neither did Jesse's classmates at Lincoln Middle School, who say Jesse bragged about a new job with "his uncle." "He said he loved going to work," said 13-year-old Carol Trembly, whose father drove Jesse's school bus. Police responding to a pre-dawn 911 call on Sunday, Sept. 26, discovered a much more harrowing situation. As a frantic Davis Carpenter led them to Jesse's limp, naked body, police noticed drug paraphernalia and duct tape lying nearby. Hours later, Joshua Brown confessed that he sneaked behind Jesse, bound and gagged the boy, and then sodomized him repeatedly as Mr. Carpenter watched and gave instructions. After taking a break to eat a sandwich at about 5 a.m., Mr. Brown discovered Jesse had stopped breathing. The boy died at the hospital. Police found chilling notes and diagrams illustrating the rape, allegedly written from Mr. Carpenter to Mr. Brown. According to police reports, the notes referred to making "him" take "those pills" and telling "him" not to resist or he would continue to be sexually assaulted. "Even the police officers who have investigated homicide, shootings, and rape in the past were taken aback by what they saw," said Rogers Police Chief Tim Keck, calling the case one of "the most brutal" he has seen. Mr. Carpenter and Mr. Brown, who are being held in Benton County Jail in Bentonville, are charged with capital murder and six counts of rape; authorities haven't set a trial date. Despite local outrage, the national press was not so taken aback. For weeks, reporters ignored the Durkhising murder, prompting charges of bias. For at the same time that newspapers did not cover Jesse's case, they continued their year-long blitz on the Matthew Shepard case-a media fest that began last October when two heterosexual men beat to death the 21-year-old homosexual college student. Following Mr. Shepard's murder, the Associated Press (AP) ran national news stories every day for a week with the words "openly gay student" prominently displayed in headlines. But Jesse's murder did not make the AP national wire, with the exception of one story appearing almost a month after the crime. "If this were an openly gay boy assaulted to death by two heterosexual men, I don't think there would be any doubt this would be a national news story," said Tim Graham, director of media analysis for the Virginia-based Media Research Center (MRC). MRC research revealed that most major newspapers, national television networks, and newsmagazines shunned the Dirkhising murder. Why the neglect? "This story has the potential to short-circuit the current appeal of gay politics-which is to focus on gays as victims of violence, not as perpetrators," Mr. Graham explained. Homosexual advocacy groups like the Human Rights Campaign (HRC) remained silent about the Dirkhising killing. "It's a horrible, brutal crime and we feel for the family and everyone else affected, but we're not sure it would be our place to comment," HRC spokesman Wayne Besen told WORLD. "Their sexual orientation was irrelevant to that fact. It was two guys who did a horrible thing." But earlier this year, HRC was unwilling to attribute Mr. Shepard's murder simply to two guys doing a horrible thing. HRC spokeswoman Kim Hill blamed Mr. Shepard's murder on "a climate of intolerance ... fostered by religious political organizations such as the Family Research Council, Focus on the Family, and the Christian Coalition." The Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation joined HRC in attacking Christians, calling a "Truth in Love" advertising campaign featuring testimonies from former homosexuals "meanspirited" and "deceptive." The Matthew Shepard case was an opportunity to be exploited; the Jesse Dirkhising case is a danger to be downplayed. But at least some Arkansans wonder how this could have happened. "It's unlikely there is just one victim," said Rogers resident Susan Nemec, whose 12-year-old son often accompanied her to Dixieland Mall where Mr. Carpenter worked. She recalls the hair stylist as a "charming man" who changed his hair color every other week: "I never felt like he was a predator." The son of another mall employee was more discerning. Sitting beside his father's cash register at one of the mall's food stations, a pale-faced 14-year-old boy quietly told of Mr. Carpenter's advances, requesting that his name be withheld. "He kept telling me I needed a haircut and that he wouldn't charge," said the boy, who often delivered food to the hair salon. Asked why he didn't accept, the boy responded, "He seemed a little too friendly. I just had a weird feeling." The tight-knit communities of Prairie Grove and Lincoln, populations 2,240 and 1,682, respectively, wish Jesse had had the same feeling.

We see you’ve been enjoying the content on our exclusive member website. Ready to get unlimited access to all of WORLD’s member content?
Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.
(Don’t worry. It only takes a sec—and you don’t have to give us payment information right now.)

Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.


You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading


    Life with Lyme

    For long-term Lyme patients, treatment is a matter of…