Columnists > Mailbag


Issue: "Motel 1600," Sept. 6, 1997

Market-driven fads

I read the article on Christian bookselling ("Whatever happened to Christian publishing?" July 12/19) with great interest. I have owned a Christian bookstore for 24 years. I have watched the industry go from ministry driven to market driven. Part of the fault lies with customers. If customers would not buy into fads we would not have to sell the stuff. As much as I would like to sell just quality Christian books, I would not be in business very long. Good, solid, thought-provoking, life-changing books just don't sell all that well in this town. - Joan Nienhuis, Oak Harbor, Wash.

Odd advertising

Your magazine's consistent evaluation of the Christian subculture with objective truth is encouraging; yet your inside cover advertising the Rev. Robert Schuller's new book is a prime example of the trends in Christian publishing. Hasn't the Rev. Schuller and his ministry been engaging in the type of self-help which the article decries? It seems odd that this advertisement is opposite the cover that questions the theological integrity of Christian publishing. - Jason A. Greer, Greenville, S.C.

Good books rare

We see you’ve been enjoying the content on our exclusive member website. Ready to get unlimited access to all of WORLD’s member content?
Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.
(Don’t worry. It only takes a sec—and you don’t have to give us payment information right now.)

Get your risk-free, 30-Day FREE Trial Membership right now.

Thank you for your coverage of the changes that are happening in the publishing industry. As a school/church librarian, I have observed the deterioration of the materials available to the Christian community for a long time. Searching for a book with good content is like searching for gold, and the great classics of the past cannot be found many times because they are not being republished. - R. T. Helland, Olalla, Wash.

Pagan publishers

Your issue on Christian publishing is very accurate and reflects only in part what is going on in evangelical publishing. Missing: Ingram's takeover of Spring Arbor, the largest distributor to Christian bookstores. As a publisher of non-fluff authors like A. W. Tozer and A. B. Simpson, I am increasingly frustrated by pagans in the publisher's chair. - K. Neill Foster , Camp Hill, Penn.

- ,

Butterfly kisses

What is the point of the attack on Bob Carlisle? Your unwarranted, cynical attack and criticism is a major disappointment. - Carol I. Winstead, Jackson, Miss.

More butterfly kisses

As a youth worker and worship leader, I was disappointed with Mr. Orteza's "Fluttery fatherhood." I understand the need in Christian music for pointed, biblical lyrics, but I don't think we should bash artists for expounding on a concept that isn't anti-scriptural. - D. Matty, Grand Island, Neb.

And more

Mr. Orteza is far too critical of Bob Carlisle's moving song. Who cares if it is not the most theologically deep song ever written? If it is making an impact in the secular world of music, then Mr. Carlisle's efforts should be applauded, not criticized. - Stuart A. Kruse, Auburn, Ind.

Butterfly value

The primary problem with this small-minded review is that it overlooks the great value of the mega-hit "Butterfly Kisses." Because of this song's popularity, hundreds of thousands of unchurched, non-Christians will purchase this album and be exposed to the potent gospel message contained throughout this CD. - Paul Comfort, Sudlersville, Maryland

Butterfly wisdom

So "Butterfly Kisses" is not "biblical wisdom." Do you really think the average man on the street wants to hear that? You have to hit them where they live. And if the marketing strategists get copies into more secular homes, at least it's music with integrity. - Suzanne Mayo, Gahanna, Ohio

Cheers for Bob

What's the problem with Arsenio Orteza? I would rather have my sons listen to a song about real love than the one-gland-calling-to-another lust that is standard fare in most teen songs. Three cheers for Bob and Butterflies! - Lynne Breidenbach, Lakeland, Fla.


You must be a WORLD member to post comments.

    Keep Reading


    Troubling ties

    Under the Clinton State Department, influence from big money…